Bar ditches
In high school, I ran cross country.
And we’ll pause there for a moment for those who know me personally to attempt to deal with the cognitive dissonance of comparing my present condition with mental images of sleek, gazelle-like distance runners. (Don’t bother trying too hard. You’ll not be able to resolve the incongruities: even as a much thinner teen I looked more like a wrestler than a runner.)1
Now that we’ve dealt with that, let’s head back to the late 70s, back to when I discovered what we in the Texas Panhandle, where I’d moved recently, call bar ditches. I’d never lived in an agricultural region before, and when we sleek, gazelle-like athletes (and Eric) went for training runs early in the mornings before class, we regularly headed out of town. And as we ran down the long, straight, flat country roads, drainage ditches on both sides of the slightly cambered unpaved surface faithfully ran alongside.
I don’t know why we called these ubiquitous drainage features “bar ditches,” and I don’t know whether that’s a Texas Panhandle colloquialism or a term common to other North American agricultural regions.2
But the repeated experience of their presence during innumerable hours of pounding my way along caliche roads decades ago has seared them into my memory. And I’ve found that they also provide a useful metaphor for an interesting dynamic in life.
The interesting dynamic
A wise writer I respect noted that problems tend to come in pairs.3 Often it’s two lies that are seemingly unconnected, except that they “bracket” the truth, and represent errors diverging from the truth in two different and possibly opposite ways.
And this is where the metaphor comes into play: when you’re out for a long training run on a country road, stay out of the bar ditches!!
Board oversight
And when you’re on the long trek of participating in governance by serving on a board, be aware that oversight bar ditches lie right alongside, and that it’s very, very easy to stray into them and bog down and otherwise get off track.
As I noted in the preceding blog article,4 boards are involved in leadership, but their leadership is qualitatively different than management’s.
Leaders provide direction, drive execution, ensure effective accountability – and actively communicate to accomplish the first three tasks. But, for a board, (a) direction is at the metaphorical 30,000’ level; (b) there is zero involvement in execution; and (c) accountability and communication are solely with management.5
That is the sweet spot, the traffic-bearing country road of effective governance (…which, like any unpaved country road, may still be rough and bumpy and rutted in spots and can, in stormy times, become difficult and even treacherous to navigate, but which, at any time and in any weather, makes for safer traveling than the bar ditches).
Bar ditch #1
As I’ve worked with and served on boards, I’ve experienced and observed the treacherous bar ditches on both sides of the road.
We’ll examine both, but let’s start with the one that’s easiest to become aware of – and it’s easiest to become aware of because it’s the one where, if you’re paying attention, you’ll likely find that management is acutely aware and possibly openly grumbling about it.
This is when the board is too active, when it usurps management’s leadership responsibilities. You’ll hear management express their frustration in a variety of ways: “They’re in my business.” “They’ve strayed out of their lane.” “They are breathing down my neck.” “Micromanaging!” “Meddling!”
Viewed through the lens of the key elements of leadership, it means the board is (a) providing tactical, operational direction; (b) getting involved in execution (making operational decisions that are management’s prerogative); (c) communicating with and requiring accountability from folks below the executive level in the organization.
This is serious and dangerous. Boards that meddle, don’t stay in their lane, and try to do management’s job are doing something damaging (demeaning and conveying a lack of trust in their management team) and simultaneously failing to do what they, as fiduciaries, are required to do: provide governance oversight at the 30,000’ level. When they are fumbling around in the weeds trying to manage, they are not providing and cannot provide oversight. Oversight requires being above and out of the daily “in the fray” details. Being out of and above the day-to-day is the position and posture and mindset that puts the “over” in oversight.6
So, directors, if you find yourself caught in this dynamic: get out of the weeds; let management do their job; eschew execution; and focus on the hard and valuable work of providing effective governance oversight in your lane.
The other bar ditch
The first ditch involves usurping management’s role. The opposite bar ditch is abdicating your own.
The first manifests in hyperactivity – too much activity and the wrong kind of activity; the second bar ditch manifests in passivity.
And it’s much harder to detect, partly because management likely will not object to a docile, passive board. But it’s also hard to detect because the primary activity going on in a passive board’s typical meeting may look quite a bit like normal, healthy on-the-roadway interaction: lots of presentations by management and some discussion involving the board.
But what makes for a vital difference is the nature and quality of the discussions, and the responses from the board to the presentations by management. (More about both of these in the next blog article.)
In bar ditch #1, the board is executing and directing and communicating and expecting accountability, and all at the operational level (which means, as a consequence, it’s not providing strategic direction and accountability). In bar ditch #2, the board doesn’t stray into management’s execution lane…because it’s not doing much of anything of substance, including not providing 30,000’ level direction7 and, significantly, not holding management accountable for its responsibilities.
When a board abdicates, one of the most effective mechanisms for ensuring continuity of mission and vision and values across time is lost. And if the board won’t hold management accountable, who else will?
Directors are stewards. No one else can do a board’s job for it. Management may prefer not being held accountable. But the shareholders and other external constituencies won’t appreciate it and will suffer from the lack.
But accountability is hard
True enough.
Tough. Get over it.
Attending meetings and hobnobbing and being in the know about proprietary secrets can be enjoyable and maybe even a bit titillating. But those don’t create much value.
Here’s what does create value: (1) bringing long-horizon, multifaceted perspectives alongside management’s as you together set long-term strategy consistent with the organization’s deeply held vision and mission and values, and then (2) holding management accountable for executing on that strategic direction.
Again: if you won’t do it, who will – and especially as it relates to strategic accountability?
Holding others accountable can create tension and disagreement and discomfort and all manner of unpleasantness. But we expect management not to shun that vital, sometimes challenging responsibility with their teams. Why should the board get a pass? And again, if a board won’t do it with management, who will?8
Healthy tension
We would all prefer a calm, comfortable, collegial environment with low stress and zero drama.
But not all tension is bad – even if it is uncomfortable. Some tension can be healthy.
Peter Drucker’s wisdom on effective board governance makes this point well:
“Top management, by and large, does not want a really effective board. An effective board demands top-management performance and removes top executives who do not perform adequately—that is its duty. An effective board asks inconvenient questions. And effective board insists on being informed before the event—that is its legal responsibility. An effective board will not unquestioningly accept the recommendations of top management but will want to know why. It will not rubber-stamp the personnel decisions of top management but will want to know, indeed to get personally acquainted with, alternative candidates for senior appointments. An effective board, in other words, insists on being effective.”9
Demanding performance (just like management does with their teams). Removing non-performers (ditto). Asking inconvenient questions, insisting on being informed, expecting good explanations (ditto, ditto, ditto). An effective board, when effective, is active in performing its role. Even when it’s hard. Even when it makes management wriggle. And especially when management loses sight of those long-horizon priorities that the board and management are both charged with stewarding.
It’s something to think about
Board member: govern well. Stay out of those bar ditches. Don’t do management’s job; but do make sure management does its job.
Providing governing oversight is not easy. And it may make you and the other directors and management uncomfortable from time to time. But this stewardship leadership role is too important not to do it and do it well. And when it is done well, the contribution to the long-term health and fruitfulness of the organization and of all the people it touches is significant.
Next time: “I have a question…” (effective oversight in action)
Eric R. Alexander
November 2024
No A.I was employed (or harmed) in the creation of this content.
© 2024, Six Arrows Consulting. All rights reserved.
1 On a downtown street in Philadelphia about 10 years ago, when I still “ran” reasonably frequently, a dog on a leash I encountered while waiting for the walk sign at an intersection mistook me for a fireplug (short, squat, red from exertion…and not moving very fast).
2 Remember: I’m a city boy.
3 C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity, p.186 (1952; HarperCollins edition 2001)
4 Effective oversight from a Board: life at 30,000′
5 See the blog article referenced above for some important clarifications and nuances on all of these statements.
6 Please note: I’m not assuming nefarious motives for directors on meddlesome boards. They may have simply stepped into a seat with a board that has developed bad habits over decades. And it’s very likely no one has ever told them it can and should be different.
7 Usually developed in concert with management.
8 Accountability doesn’t have to be unpleasant or heavy handed (though it certainly can be). See this blog article for thoughts on that: Accountability can have a soft touch
9 Peter Drucker, Management: Tasks, Responsibilities, Practices, p.629 (Harper Row, 1974). Emphasis added. Do not mistake this quote as Drucker advocating for board meddling. He elsewhere makes clear he understands, for instance, the importance of decisions being made at the right level in an organization: “It is a law of governance that it restrict itself to necessary decisions. Any governing body will be the more effective, and more powerful, the more it eschews decisions it does not have to make.” (p.282); and “A decision should always be made at the lowest possible level and as close to the scene of the action as possible. However, a decision should always be made at a level insuring that all activities and objectives affected are fully considered. The first rule tells us how far down a decision should be made. The second how far down it can be made, as well as which managers must share in the decision and which must be informed of it.” (p.545) Emphasis in the original for both of these quotes.