Effective oversight from a Board (part 3): “I have a question…”

Dec 11, 2024 | Blog

6 min read

On the scene

In countless board rooms across the country (and in the couple of handful of them I’ve spent time in, either as a director or as part of management), the scene and tone are reasonably consistent: management sets the agenda and calmly, confidently drives the meeting, and information flows –  in the form of verbal and written updates, slide presentations of varying degrees of flashiness and sophistication, financial updates in columnar and oral and graphical format, and much more – from management to the board. Not always, but often. And the role of the board can feel rather passive. Again, not always, but quite often.

And, in the midst of the constant activity and communication initiated by management, the board still must exercise good governance and oversight which includes holding management accountable.

A key part of the interaction model

A natural and essential and highly effective way for board members to provide oversight and accountability is simply to ask good questions.

Questions can help all of you around the conference table identify whether relevant factors for the decision or situation are being addressed. They can prompt management to think harder and plan more thoroughly and carefully – and ensure important factors and context beyond the immediate situation or problem are considered. Of course, management may not always appreciate your questions, especially difficult or challenging ones. But if you ask them with good motives, a professional tone and a stewardship perspective, they are a key tool in your board toolbox – even the difficult ones, the ones that might make management squirm a bit.1

Categories of good questions

Not all questions are created equal. I’ve seen board meetings bog down with directors asking detailed and even inane questions that cause the meeting to spin out of control and skid way out of the governance and oversight lane.

Ask good, smart questions.

Consider these categories (plus a few other randoms I’ll toss in for good measure afterwards):

  • Context. As management presents a problem or an opportunity or reports on operating results, ask about the other things going on around that situation that could have a bearing on it or be affected by it. And key context aspects to keep in the discussion mix at all times are those high-level, fundamental matters entrusted to your shared stewardship: mission, values, culture, strategy.
  • Clarification. Generally, the management team members in the room are the subject matter experts on the topics under discussion or consideration. That means they may, in their communicating with you, forget to translate industry or technical or company-specific details and nuances into clear, layperson terms. You must understand what’s being talked about. Don’t let the fear of exposure of your own relative ignorance keep management and the rest of the board from benefiting from your enhanced ability to participate if you understand what the heck is going on. And you just might not be the only one who needs some clarity.
  • Consequences. This one can be tricky given that it’s inherently conjectural. But some conjectures about consequences are based on deep experience. So ask what management expects will happen – to customers, to financial performance, to market position, to enterprise value, to the company’s risk profile – if the recommended action is taken. And pay especial attention to ripple effects, and ask about it that way (though in whatever terms sound most professional to you): yes, we expect this (which is why we’re doing it, or because it’s a common outcome), but what are secondary and tertiary effects elsewhere in the organization and among your various constituencies? Speaking of which…
  • Constituencies. You represent the shareholders (if you’re in a for-profit entity). But various other groups of people have a stake in what the company does. Ask about effects on customers, employees, vendors, communities. Ask about what regulators will think about it (if relevant).
  • Culture. You are, alongside the management team, a steward of the company’s culture – your shared, lived values. Asking questions about culture implications or adherence to shared values may feel touchy feely. Or you may not as an organization have carefully articulated exactly what is important to you along these lines. If you haven’t, find a time to do so. If you have, get over the discomfort with the topic possibly being vague and anecdotal and hard to measure. If it’s truly important to the company, it should be a regular part of the conversations at the highest level.
  • CAMELS. This acronym comes from the banking world (capital, asset quality, management, earnings, liquidity and sensitivity to interest rate risk) and it captures some of the most significant risk and opportunity categories that regulators monitor (and which the management and board of the bank must also pay attention to). Other industries will have their own key risk and opportunity items (these are worth identifying). Ask about them. When a topic on one is under discussion (let’s talk about earnings today), ask questions about how that relates to the others (what does that mean regarding capital, for example) – for the interplay among them is real and significant and easily overlooked.

And these other questions can be super powerful:

  • What assumptions are we making in this discussion, in this decision?
  • What factors (including those in the categories above) are in tension with each other, and what do we do about that?
  • What external factors are involved?
  • What decision making biases might we be prone to but overlooking right now?2
  • What are the opportunity costs of this decision? (by saying yes to option A, you are saying no to options B to Z).
  • How will we know if we’ve made the right decision? What constitutes success and failure?
  • What are the key factors that are relevant for the range of outcomes?
  • Do we have the right people in the room (or at least in the conversation over time) on this topic? Are there other voices or experts we need to involve?
  • What are we overlooking?

What questions did we fail to ask?

When and how

We’ve already addressed the why and the what about directors asking good questions. But when should you ask them? And how?

First, when. And it’s easy. All the time. Ask questions about normal operations and financial performance. Ask questions about strategic direction and your shared values and the state of the economy. Ask questions as management proposes strategic initiatives and later unveils plans for execution. Ask about the pulse of your people.

How? Calmly and professionally. And insistently if management pushes back or ignores you (assuming your question is relevant and insightful).

The question asking may generate some tension within the board or with management or both. But tension can be healthy.3 You can always be 100% truthful in your probing and 100% respectful to those you are questioning.

It’s something to think about

Board member: brush up on your question asking skills. Go to each meeting prepared to ask one or several. Take along a cheat list of topics and examples (see above for ideas).

Over time, you’ll find (a) you’re learning more about the organization; (b) management is more on its toes in the level and quality of information and analysis and recommendations it brings for your consideration; (c) accountability is happening automatically and naturally;4 and (d) governance and oversight will flow more readily from the enriched and expanded conversation between the board and management and within the board.

Ask away.

Next time: “But I’m not an expert…” (effective oversight in action, cont.)

Eric R. Alexander

December 2024

 

No A.I was employed (or harmed) in the creation of this content.

© 2024, Six Arrows Consulting. All rights reserved.

 1 This paragraph closely tracks one from a Dec. 2023 blog article that touched on this topic: What a nonbanker needs to know about serving on a bank board (For another blog article that also touched on this topic, see Accountability can have a light touch from April 2024.)

2 A subject for an entirely different discussion. If you’re unfamiliar with the concept, Google or ChatGPT can give you a quick sketch of common ones. I also highly recommend Noise: a flaw in human judgment by Daniel Kahneman, Olivier Sibony and Cass R. Sunstein (Hachette Book Group, 2021).

3 For more on this, see the Nov. 2024 blog article: Effective oversight from a Board: stay out of the bar ditches

4 Not that other more pointed accountability conversations won’t occasionally be appropriate and necessary.

Note: the Drucker quote is from Management: Taks, Responsibilities, Practices, p.629 (Harper Row, 1974). The Flyvbjerg quote is from How Big Things Get Done, pp.41-42 (Penguin Random House, 2023).