Me, neither
I came to banking nearly 70% of the way into my business career.1 This meant that, though I’d had extensive experience on the other side of the credit relationship in a prior CFO role, much was new and unfamiliar in this new industry.
But it didn’t take me long to discover I wasn’t the only one regularly dealing with unfamiliar concepts and terms and acronyms. Many of the directors serving on our Board also came from outside banking. And I presently serve on two Boards in an industry where I am very much the technical laggard and neophyte in the room when management and the other directors and I gather for our Board meetings.
How can I provide effective oversight if I’m not an expert?
A Board member is tasked with the vital responsibility of serving ably as part of a group that together provides governance oversight for management and the company. But how can I do that well as a director when I am not an industry insider or otherwise technically up-to-speed?
The punchline
Effective oversight does not require technical mastery.
That’s what I’ve concluded based on experiences and observations over time. Let’s walk through several principles to help see why that is the case.
- Principle 1: the group of people involved in a function within the company must, collectively, possess the expertise and sophistication appropriate for the complexity of that function.
For example, the Finance department as a team must have all the relevant, up-to-date knowledge and experience and expertise required to handle financial reporting, payables, taxes, general accounting, GAAP interpretation and application, and financial planning and analysis (and more) timely and with excellence. But that does not mean each person in the Finance department has (or could reasonably be expected to have) the expertise appropriate for every aspect of the bundle of complexities. But the team as a whole must.
- Principle 2: the level of expertise and sophistication required to oversee a group of experts does not have to exceed the specific and detailed expertise of each member in the group.
It’s likely obvious as soon as I state it. And you can think of numerous examples across all of life.
Back to our Finance department example: it’s not practical or necessary for the CFO overseeing the department to be the preeminent expert in each area. Perhaps she is the former Controller and knows the GAAP and GL and financial reporting and general accounting functions inside out. But that doesn’t mean she has to be the department expert on taxes and payables and FP&A and the rest – as long as she does have competent experts handling operational execution in those other areas.
A view of what this hypothetical department might look like:

Observations:
- In each Finance department sub-function (save one), the staff and leaders have more expertise than is required relative to the complexity of that sub-function.
- And given the composite expertise within each sub-function’s team, the CFO doesn’t have to have all of the requisite expertise in each sub-function herself. In anything beyond a small Finance shop, that wouldn’t be realistic anyway.
- Look at the situation in General Accounting: the CFO, as former Controller who stepped up into the new role from leading this sub-function, is clearly the dominant expert still. And this provides some time for her new replacement (less skilled and experienced in the role) to grow from his level of relatively less expertise.2 But the new Controller must steadily bring his expertise up to match the level the CFO/former Controller possesses. If he doesn’t, the CFO will have to provide an abnormal level of support and direct involvement into the foreseeable future that goes beyond normal oversight. (And, in a configuration not shown above, should the CFO and the Controller + Gen Acct team collectively fail to maintain the level of expertise relevant for the complexity in this sub-function, a disaster is on the horizon.)
Back to the Boardroom
As a CFO, I’ve lived something very much like the hypothetical diagram above myself.
But what does this have to do with Board members and their oversight responsibilities?
Everything.
The CFO-Finance department example applies to the Board’s oversight responsibilities for the company as a near-perfect analogy.
- Principle 1 restated: the group of people involved in actively running the company must, collectively, possess the expertise and sophistication appropriate for the complexity of the company and its operating environment.
- Principle 2 restated: the level of expertise and sophistication required for the Board to oversee the management team running the company does not have to exceed the specific and detailed expertise of each member of the management team (and their respective direct-report experts).
Another hypothetical view:

Observations: (a) as long as management possesses the expertise appropriate for the company’s complexity, the Board does not need to match or exceed it; (b) but if both aren’t equipped for the complexity, disaster is inevitable.
The Board serves as a group
And here’s where the CFO/Finance department example breaks down: the CFO is a single individual overseeing a vital function. The Board is a group of directors collectively providing oversight for the company. That means, in practice, that the relative sophistication and expertise of the Board is a blend of the strengths and perspectives and experiences of the full Board membership.
And that can look like this:

Each Board member will have his or her own level of sophistication and expertise on any given topic (which is an oversimplification in the visual above, since it condenses all the relevant areas of complexity and expertise into a single vertical view). In some cases, like on the Audit Committee of the Board, a specific director may be the designated expert (sometimes mandated by law). In all instances, each director (even one not “native” to the industry) should possess or rapidly gain more expertise and knowledge than a random man or woman on the street.
Practical suggestions
I boldly stated above that effective oversight does not require technical mastery. And I indicated that I’ve lived that out in my Finance leadership roles; I’ve also observed it at work within effective Boards.
But this is not an excuse for oversight passivity – either for CFOs or for directors. Just because technical mastery isn’t required doesn’t mean the oversight job is simple or easy.
Effective oversight doesn’t require technical mastery. But it does require the following – and intentional, persistent growth in each of them:
- Familiarity with general principles of each area of technical expertise.
- An understanding of the primary risks of each area of technical expertise.
- An understanding of all significant assumptions involved in key decisions.
- Confidence in the knowledge, expertise and integrity of all of the experts.
- The ability to ask probing, clarifying questions.3
- A thorough understanding of the company’s mission, vision, values and strategy.
And, significantly, whenever the company undertakes (or otherwise experiences) a step-change in its operational complexity, the Board must ensure that both it and the management team take commensurate step-changes in their own levels of sophistication – and preferably ahead of the change.
It’s something to think about
Board member: your participation in providing governance oversight for your company is valuable and significant. Don’t let your relative lack of expertise intimidate you. You can (and must!) still provide effective oversight. It’s the important reason you are in that vital stewardship leadership role.
Serve well. The company and its various constituencies are depending on you to do so.
Eric R. Alexander
January 2025
No A.I was employed (or harmed) in the creation of this content.
© 2024, Six Arrows Consulting. All rights reserved.
1 …based on elapsed time as of the date of the article. The final and precise percentage will, of course, depend on how long the career continues. Feel free to check back 5, 10 or 15 years from now for a revised calculation.
2 Not that I’d suggest hiring someone into this important a position with this large of a gap relative to the complexity he’ll have to manage. But it may avoid being a disaster if the CFO stays more hands-on than would otherwise we optimal.
3 For more on this, see the Nov. 2024 blog article: Effective oversight from a Board: “I have a question…” (Note: it can also be helpful to have at least some ability to detect and call out B.S.)
Earlier blog articles in this series:
- Oct 2024: Effective oversight from a Board: life at 30,000′
- Nov 2024: Effective oversight from a Board: stay out of the bar ditches
- Dec 2024: Effective oversight from a Board: “I have a question…”
See also: What a nonbanker needs to know about serving on a bank board