Meet Wojciech
Last month, Wojciech (VOY-chekh) Kaleta, a contact on social media, emailed me with a question about my perspective on how stewardship relates to a problem he has been working on professionally: when and how an organization should reopen a decision. (Wojciech is a Decision Engineer and researcher based in Poland working at the intersection of decision authority, human factors, situational awareness, and human–AI decision systems. Drawing on two decades of experience in maritime aviation, his work focuses on how organizations determine whether the evidence, assumptions and conditions that originally justified a consequential decision still support continued action over time.)
What ensued was a fascinating email exchange over the following two weeks.
The conversation
Wed, Sep 2, 2026
Eric,
I spent some time with your work on stewardship, and one aspect in particular stayed with me: the idea that leadership is temporary, while responsibility is exercised over something entrusted to us rather than simply owned by us.
That connects with a question I have been exploring from a somewhat different angle.
Much of my work focuses on consequential decisions and on what happens when the conditions that originally justified a decision materially change, while responsibility for that decision remains with the same person or institution. It leaves me with a question I would genuinely value your perspective on:
When the basis of an important decision changes, does stewardship require only that the leader remains accountable for the decision and its consequences — or does it also require recognizing when the authority carried forward from that earlier decision should itself be reopened?
I suspect our starting points are different enough to make the comparison useful, rather than merely confirmatory.
Best regards,
Wojciech
Wed, Sep 2, 2026
Wojciech –
Do you have an example (hypothetical or otherwise) that illustrates the situation you’re evaluating?
Thanks.
Eric
Thu, Sep 3, 2026
Eric,
Absolutely. Let me make it concrete with a hypothetical example.
Imagine a CFO approves a significant technology investment based on a set of conditions that are reasonable at the time: expected cost savings, a particular implementation scope, known operational risks, available internal capability, and a credible fallback option if the program underperforms.
Twelve months later, the program is still active and the original approval has never been formally withdrawn. But several things have changed. The scope has expanded, internal dependency on the technology has increased, the fallback option has become much harder to exercise, and some of the assumptions that supported the original decision no longer describe the organization as it now operates.
Nothing has necessarily “failed.” The program may even be performing reasonably well.
The question I am interested in is this: What does stewardship require of the CFO at that point? Is stewardship satisfied by continuing to own the consequences of the original decision and ensuring responsible execution? Or does stewardship also create an obligation to recognize that the basis on which the organization originally said “yes” has materially changed and therefore to reopen whether that earlier approval should still carry forward?
I would be very interested in how you would frame it from a stewardship perspective.
Best,
Wojciech
Wed, Sep 9, 2026
Wojciech –
Thanks for the hypothetical example.
My view: A steward clearly has a responsibility and obligation to respond to the changes in the context for execution of the decision.
Various reasons:
- The steward leader is responsible for the broader purpose and not just the decision itself: the “why,” and not merely the “what.”
- Even if raising the issue for re-consideration means execution responsibility shifts away from the steward (diminishing the scope of responsibility, shrinking “my little kingdom”), that’s completely beside the point: the steward serves and leads for the benefit of the organization and its constituencies. His or her personal prominence or prestige is beside the point.
- Effective stewarding is handled best by teams of steward leaders who collectively and collaboratively protect and nurture what has been entrusted to them. If Messi needs to pass the ball to another player with a better shot at the goal, that’s always the right decision.
- Stewards make hard decisions. Even decisions that diminish their own remit. Even decisions that involve reopening what’s been considered a closed matter.
- Stewards pay attention to the internal and external contexts of their responsibilities and of the organization they serve in. Simply barreling forward with a decided path while ignoring relevant impinging factors is irresponsible.
All of these rationales flow directly and naturally from the essential elements of stewardship.
Thanks for the question. I’d love to hear your thoughts as well.
Regards,
Eric
Thu, Sep 10, 2026
Eric,
Thank you.
What I find particularly interesting is that your answer does not treat stewardship as responsibility for preserving the original decision. It treats it as responsibility for protecting the broader purpose and what has been entrusted, even when that requires reopening a matter that was previously considered settled.
That distinction matters to me. It also suggests a further question.
If we agree that a steward has an obligation to respond when the context materially changes, then the harder problem may be determining when that threshold has actually been crossed. In other words:
- What should make a steward say, “the conditions have changed enough that continuing under the earlier decision is no longer sufficient; this now needs to be reopened”?
- Is that judgment primarily driven by consequences, changes in assumptions, changes in purpose-fit, loss of reversibility, changes in risk, or something else in your stewardship framework?
I ask because one of the problems I keep encountering is that organizations are often quite good at noticing change, but much less clear about when change becomes decision-relevant enough to invalidate continuation on the old basis.
Your point about the broader purpose seems especially important here, because it may mean the trigger is not simply “the original plan is failing,” but “the original decision no longer serves what was entrusted.”
I’d be very interested in how you would draw that boundary.
Best,
Wojciech
Fri, Sep 11, 2026
Wojciech –
Two thoughts:
- Perhaps the precise boundary or time point for reopening the question is less important than (a) understanding that this option is even on the table for consideration, (b) a willingness to reopen the question when that’s appropriate, and (c) attentiveness to all the conditions, internal and external, that provide relevant data for the decision.
- Peter Drucker addresses this indirectly in his thinking on “sloughing off yesterday” in The Effective Executive:
- “The first rule of the concentration of executive efforts is to slough off the past that has ceased to be productive. Effective executives periodically review their work programs…and ask: ‘If we did not already do this, would we go into it now?'”
- “Yesterday’s successes…always linger on long beyond their productive life. Even more dangerous are the activities which should do well and which, for some reason or other, do not produce…. Unless they are pruned, and pruned ruthlessly, they drain the lifeblood from an organization.”
- “The executive who wants to be effective and who wants his organization to be effective polices all programs, all activities, all tasks, [and, in my opinion, all policies, all systems, all procedures]. He always asks: ‘Is this still worth doing?’ And if it isn’t, he gets rid of it so as to be able to concentrate on the few tasks that, if done with excellence, will really make a difference in the results of his own job and in the performance of his organization.”1
An organization can operationalize this continual review of the past decisions by building it into the normal flow of the formal strategic planning process. In an effective strategic planning process, leadership focuses on connecting their decisions and efforts now and in the near term to the big, consequential organizational aspirations (mission, vision, values — why do we exist). And the strategy decisions involve shaping what we want the “new normal” to look like going into the future to accomplish those aspirations. It’s easy just to pile one new initiative on top of all the things already going on; it takes lots of courage and discipline to see what needs to be pruned or sloughed off to make the “new normal” maximally fruitful.
A regular (at least annual) review of material existing initiatives from this perspective would ensure that (1) the executive team and board are consciously considering the possibility of reopening a decision on a regular basis; and (2) doing so on a cadence that, for large, long-lived initiatives, should mean too much time doesn’t elapse between when the basis for the change occurs (any or all of the reasons you cited: “consequences, changes in assumptions, changes in purpose-fit, loss of reversibility, changes in risk”) and when the topic is back up for discussion.
For less material matters, putting them on a cycle for periodic review would be more practical than reopening every decision on policy, product, processes, initiatives every year.
Thoughts?
Regards,
Eric
Mon, Sep 14, 2026
Eric,
Thank you. This moves the discussion in a direction I find particularly useful.
I think your first point is important: before we worry about finding a perfectly precise threshold, the organization has to preserve three more basic things — the possibility of reopening, the willingness to do it, and attentiveness to the conditions that might make it necessary. Your connection to Drucker also helps. The question “Would we go into it now?” is a powerful way of testing whether continued activity is being justified by present conditions or merely carried forward by history.
Where I think I would add one further layer is timing.
A regular strategic review seems to me an excellent backstop, particularly for long-lived initiatives. But I wonder whether stewardship also requires a way to reopen a decision between those scheduled reviews when something materially changes.
For example, imagine that an annual review has just confirmed continuation, but two months later one of the conditions that made the decision reasonable changes substantially. Waiting until the next annual cycle may preserve the formal review process while allowing the organization to continue for ten months on a basis that no longer describes reality.
So, I am beginning to see two complementary questions:
- Do we periodically ask whether yesterday’s decision still deserves to continue?
- Do we also know what kinds of change should bring that question forward before the next scheduled review?
The first protects against inertia. The second protects against review latency.
What I find especially interesting in your stewardship framing is that both appear to flow from responsibility for the broader purpose rather than loyalty to the prior decision itself.
That may be the point of connection I was looking for.
Best,
Wojciech
Mon, Sep 14, 2026
Wojciech –
Short answer: an emphatic yes. Where we’ve landed in this discussion is absolutely consistent with the stewardship framework I use with leaders and leadership teams.
And how you’ve framed this—with the two questions addressing both inertia and review latency—is a practical expression of the core principle you identified: the steward’s responsibility for the broader purpose.
I’m curious. What brought the initial question to the surface for you?
Regards,
Eric
Mon, Sep 14, 2026
Eric,
What brought the question to the surface is two parts of my work that increasingly began to converge.
The first is operational. My background is in maritime aviation, where decisions are often made on an incomplete picture, under time pressure, with responsibility distributed across people and systems. One lesson that stayed with me is that a decision can be entirely reasonable when it is made and still become unsafe later if the picture changes while confidence, authority or execution continue as if nothing material has changed.
The second is my current research and advisory work around decision systems, particularly consequential human–AI and organizational decisions. A recurring problem I see is not simply whether the original decision was good. It is whether the basis that justified continuing to act is still current.
That has led me to focus increasingly on questions such as:
- What changed after the original decision?
- Which assumptions or conditions were carrying the decision?
- Who is responsible for noticing when those conditions no longer hold?
- What should trigger reconsideration before consequences make the problem obvious?
- And, critically, does the organization still have the authority and practical ability to reopen the decision in time?
That is where stewardship became interesting to me.
My work has usually approached the problem through decision authority, evidence, human factors, and the continuity of justification over time. Stewardship adds a different layer: why the person holding responsibility should remain oriented toward the broader purpose rather than toward preserving the prior decision, their own remit or the appearance of consistency. Your responses have helped me see that distinction more clearly. From my side, I think the interesting intersection may be this:
- Stewardship explains why reopening can be an obligation.
- Decision architecture has to explain how an organization recognizes when that obligation has become active and how it can actually act on it before the window closes.
That is the question I am currently working on.
Best,
Wojciech
Tues, Sep 15, 2026
Wojciech –
The formulation you provided makes sense to me—as far as it goes.
Stewardship certainly explains why reopening a prior decision can be an obligation. And I agree that decision architecture is part of the stewardship operationalization to turn that broader requirement into consistent practical action. It’s clearly a necessary aspect, but not sufficient by itself.
I’ve not taken time to think methodically or comprehensively about other practical aspects of operationalizing this aspect of stewardship, but here’s what has bubbled to the surface so far:
- Training leaders to understand that they have the obligation, as stewards, to be continually attuned to the possibility of reopening a decision.
- Building communication cadences and practices that serve as reminders and prompts to consider the prior decision.
- Acknowledging and rewarding leaders who do this well.
A practical thought regarding the second bullet: Effective teams regularly brief before and after an important endeavor, whether one-off or recurring and material. I’ve heard these called debriefs, after action reports, and postmortems when performed on the back side, and briefings or pre-briefs on the front side. Maybe we need to make a practice of mid-briefs as well: check-ins during the life cycle of the decision execution to ensure we have no compelling reason to change direction.
The less bureaucratic and more habitual the better for all of these practices.
Regards,
Eric
Wed, Sep 16, 2026
Eric,
I think this adds an important layer. I agree that decision architecture is necessary but not sufficient. An organization can create a formal reopening mechanism and still fail to use it if leaders have not been taught to see reopening as part of stewardship, if the normal communication rhythm never brings prior decisions back into view, or if the culture rewards persistence more strongly than responsible reconsideration.
Your idea of “mid-briefs” is especially interesting to me.
Pre-briefs help establish the basis for action. Debriefs help us understand what happened afterward. A mid-brief creates a structured opportunity to ask, while consequences are still forming, whether the basis for continuing remains sound.
That matters because by the time a debrief tells us the original picture was no longer adequate, the organization may already have lost part of its ability to change direction.
I see the elements we have discussed as complementary rather than competing:
- Stewardship creates the obligation to remain responsible to the broader purpose.
- Leadership practice creates the willingness and habit of reopening.
- Communication cadence creates opportunities to notice and discuss change.
- Incentives influence whether leaders are rewarded or punished for doing so.
- Decision architecture determines whether recognition can actually become a changed decision in time.
And I strongly agree with your point that the less bureaucratic and more habitual these practices are, the better. A reopening mechanism that is too cumbersome to use may exist formally while remaining practically dormant.
Best,
Wojciech
It’s something to think about
I’m very grateful Wojciech contacted me to open the conversation about this topic. Thinking through implications and challenges of this aspect of operationalizing stewardship was enjoyable and valuable for both of us. I hope getting to eavesdrop on the conversation was for you as well.
No A.I. was employed by Six Arrows Consulting in editing or assembling this article.
© 2026, Six Arrows Consulting. All rights reserved.
1 Peter F. Drucker, The Effective Executive (Harper & Row, 1966), 104-106.